To my baseball experts...?

You probably drafted Halladay too early, and you DEFINITELY drafted Broxton too early. There are 30 closers out there, so you can live with drafting one from the 10th round and beyond. Also, Hamilton is way too risky to be your 6th pick. I'm sure there were others out there that are better. Also, instead of drafting a better second baseman or catcher, you went with a backup first baseman. That's a really bad move. Also, another relief pitcher is a good idea (if Broxton or K-Rod gets injured, you'll be relying on one closer to get you saves). The rest of your draft looks pretty good, though.